Bug description
There is a special case in MCP tools, where excluding the ToolCallingAutoConfiguration would be desirable. In a regular Boot application, this would be achieved through:
@SpringBootApplication(exclude = { ToolCallingAutoConfiguration.class })
public class SampleMcpClientWebfluxApplication {
//...
}
However, this does exclude the configuration, because, in my application, I use Anthropic and AnthropicChatAutoConfiguration. But that auto-configuration pulls in ToolCallingAutoConfiguration (source), which cannot be excluded independently anymore.
Environment
Spring AI 1.0.x and 1.1.x are affected.
Expected behavior
It is possible to work around this specific case, but it requires diving into the auto-configurations and figuring their dependencies.
I think using @ImportAutoConfiguration on auto-configuration classes is an anti-pattern, because it breaks the "exclusion" part of the auto-configuration contract.
What should really happen in this case is that:
1. Conditions for ToolCallingAutoConfiguration are fulfilled, so it is actiaved.
1. Conditions for AnthropicChatAutoConfiguration are fulfilled, so it is activated.
1. Anthropic is marked @AutoConfiguration(after = {ToolCallingAutoConfiguration.class}), so the ordering is taking care of for me.
By doing so, it becomes possible for users to disable auto-configurations.
Problematic classes
- [ ] ZhiPuAiChatAutoConfiguration
- [ ] MistralAiChatAutoConfiguration (assigned @SuganthiThomas 2025-10-01)
- [ ] MistralAiOcrAutoConfiguration (assigned @SuganthiThomas 2025-10-01)
- [ ] MistralAiEmbeddingAutoConfiguration (assigned @SuganthiThomas 2025-10-01)
- [ ] MistralAiModerationAutoConfiguration (assigned @SuganthiThomas 2025-10-01)
- [ ] ElevenLabsAutoConfiguration
- [ ] OpenAiChatAutoConfiguration (assigned @ielatif 2025-10-01)
- [ ] OpenAiModerationAutoConfiguration (assigned @ielatif 2025-10-01)
- [ ] OpenAiAudioTranscriptionAutoConfiguration (assigned @ielatif 2025-10-01)
- [ ] OpenAiAudioSpeechAutoConfiguration (assigned @ielatif 2025-10-01)
- [ ] OpenAiImageAutoConfiguration (assigned @ielatif 2025-10-01)
- [ ] OpenAiEmbeddingAutoConfiguration (assigned @ielatif 2025-10-01)
- [ ] OCIGenAiChatAutoConfiguration
- [ ] OCIGenAiEmbeddingAutoConfiguration
- [ ] GoogleGenAiChatAutoConfiguration
- [ ] GoogleGenAiTextEmbeddingAutoConfiguration
- [ ] MiniMaxChatAutoConfiguration
- [x] OllamaEmbeddingAutoConfiguration (#4495)
- [x] OllamaApiAutoConfiguration (#4495)
- [x] OllamaChatAutoConfiguration (#4495)
- [ ] AzureOpenAiChatAutoConfiguration (assigned @loveysuby 2025-10-02)
- [ ] AnthropicChatAutoConfiguration (assigned @loveysuby 2025-10-02)
- [ ] VertexAiGeminiChatAutoConfiguration (assigned @centrumek 2025-10-02)
- [ ] VertexAiMultiModalEmbeddingAutoConfiguration (assigned @centrumek 2025-10-02)
- [ ] VertexAiTextEmbeddingAutoConfiguration (assigned @centrumek 2025-10-02)
- [ ] BedrockConverseProxyChatAutoConfiguration
- [ ] DeepSeekChatAutoConfiguration
Each of those can be fixed independently, see #4495 for Ollama.
Fix
All @ImportAutoConfiguration should be removed. I don't know of any project who uses that annotation (if you'd like to check, their starters are in Boot directly).
This might break existing behavior, and would require thinking about the auto-configuration of excluded classes.
Comment From: tzolov
If you consider helping with this issue, please contribute a single model auto-configuration at at time. You can use the #4495 as a reference.
Comment From: SuganthiThomas
Hi, I’d like to contribute to this issue. Could you please assign it to me?
Comment From: Kehrlann
@SuganthiThomas I wouldn't assign the whole issue. But please let us know which model you'd like to tackle before submitting a PR.
Comment From: ielatif
Hello, i'd like also to contribute to this. I'll handle OpenAI auto-configurations
- OpenAiChatAutoConfiguration
- OpenAiModerationAutoConfiguration
- OpenAiAudioTranscriptionAutoConfiguration
- OpenAiAudioSpeechAutoConfiguration
- OpenAiImageAutoConfiguration
- OpenAiEmbeddingAutoConfiguration
Comment From: Kehrlann
Sure thing, @ielatif . Please ping me in the PR once it's open.
Comment From: SuganthiThomas
Hi @Kehrlann ,
I will contribute following files
MistralAiChatAutoConfiguration
MistralAiOcrAutoConfiguration
MistralAiEmbeddingAutoConfiguration
MistralAiModerationAutoConfiguration
Thank You
Comment From: loveysuby
Hello, @Kehrlann. I`d like to refactor this model.
AzureOpenAiChatAutoConfiguration
AnthropicChatAutoConfiguration
Comment From: centrumek
Hello, @Kehrlann
I'll take the following: - VertexAiGeminiChatAutoConfiguration - VertexAiMultiModalEmbeddingAutoConfiguration - VertexAiTextEmbeddingAutoConfiguration
Comment From: devbulchandani
Hey @Kehrlann, I have raise a PR fixing the following:
- GoogleGenAiChatAutoConfiguration
- GoogleGenAiTextEmbeddingAutoConfiguration
Comment From: HyunSangHan
Hi @Kehrlann, I'd like to fix:
- DeepSeekChatAutoConfiguration
Comment From: centrumek
@Kehrlann VertexAI done -> https://github.com/spring-projects/spring-ai/pull/4535
I'll take the next tasks:
- ZhiPuAiChatAutoConfiguration
- ElevenLabsAutoConfiguration
- BedrockConverseProxyChatAutoConfiguration